Rio forces Beth, Annie, and Ruby to solve a problem with a possible witness, which challenges the women's morality. Meanwhile, Annie is in an awkward position with Greg and Nancy.
Beth cleans up the mess from the bloody aftermath of Rio's gun challenge to her. Stan chooses to sleep on the couch, disgusted by Ruby's criminal actions. The grocery store crime scene reveals a potential new piece of evidence against Beth. Boomer annoys Agent Turner, but then decides to lean on Beth to get her to confess. The ladies devise a scheme to intercept the evidence, but their own moral values kick in when they realize the cost of ruining the evidence would bring. Stan chooses family over his career. Annie and Gregg continue their antics, almost blowing their cover to Sadie. Dean is depressed, knowing he will require a long recovery. Boomer blackmails Mary Pat in a most unique way. Rio reminds the ladies of a problem they have that must be dealt with, giving them a tool that may help.