While still in high school, Gregg has been in a relationship with Annie. She later becomes pregnant and the young couple get married but eventually divorce, sharing custody of their child. Gregg then meets his second wife Nancy, who co-owns a chain of mall spas in Detroit.
While his son Ben is still in high school, Gregg and Nancy file a case to have full custody battle of Ben against Annie. However, as Gregg and Annie begin to talk more, momentarily rekindle their romance and, coupled with his current marital problems, end up getting drunk and start an affair. Gregg begins to realize that he still has feelings for Annie, and admits to Nancy that he is in love with someone else. Annie however realizes that they are just reliving the past and decides not to continue her relationship with Gregg.
After Nancy gives birth to their child Dakota, the couple try to fix their marriage by going to couples counseling.